Down or synthetic? Roomy or snug? And what does a ‘comfort limit’ really mean? As summer wild camping season kicks off, Chris Townsend explains what to look for in a three-season sleeping bag.
With coronavirus restrictions easing, most of us are hankering after a post-lockdown wild camping blow-out – but is your sleeping bag up to the job?
Finding a bag that will serve you well all the way from early spring through to late autumn can be surprisingly difficult. In the August issue of The Great Outdoors, Chris Townsend reviewed the latest three-season sleeping bags on the market. You’ll find his run-down of the top performers here – but if you want to get a better of which sleeping bag will suit you best then here’s what you need to know…
What do sleeping bag temperature ratings mean?
The EN 13537 rating provides a means of comparing sleeping bags for warmth. Most companies use it or an equivalent test. It should only be used as a guide, however. It doesn’t mean you will be warm at the lowest temperature.
EN 13537 gives four ratings for a sleeping bag:
Upper Comfort Limit: the highest temperature at which a “standard man” weighing 70kg should feel comfortable.
Comfort: the lower limit at which a “standard woman” weighing 60kg in a relaxed posture such as lying on the back should be comfortable.
Lower Comfort Limit: the lower limit at which a “standard man” weighing 70kg in a rolled-up body position should be comfortable.
Extreme temperature: temperature where a standard woman will feel very cold and there is a risk of frostbite or hypothermia.
The ratings are calculated with a mannequin with 15 heating zones and temperature zones. The mannequin is dressed in thermal long-sleeved top and leggings plus long socks and placed in the sleeping bag on a mattress.
The key ratings are the Comfort and Lower Comfort ones as these give an idea of the lowest range of temperatures for comfort in a bag. Most people are likely to feel too cold for comfort long before the extreme temperature is reached. I’d take the last as meaning that the bag is unsuitable for this temperature. Indeed, I think the Extreme rating is potentially so misleading that it should be scrapped.
Which fill – synthetic or down?
- Lower cost
- Retain some warmth when wet
- Reasonably quick drying
- Heavier than down for the warmth
- Bulkier to pack
- Shorter life
- Only comfortable over a narrow temperature range
- Low bulk
- Long life
- Comfortable over a wide temperature range
- Initial expense
- Slower drying
- Harder to clean
What about water-resistant down?
Some down is now hydrophobic, which means it doesn’t absorb as much moisture and it dries quicker than standard down. It doesn’t mean it’s waterproof. Whilst hydrophobic down may give some reassurance against damp I don’t think it’s significant in sleeping bags and I wouldn’t choose one sleeping bag over another because of it. I’ve used standard down bags for months at a time in places like the Scottish Highlands and never had a problem.
Is it ethical to buy a down sleeping bag?
The down used in sleeping bags comes from geese and ducks bred for food. Until a decade ago there was little concern about the conditions in which these birds were kept or how they were treated. However, investigations by environmental and animal rights organisations showed that some were force-fed for foie gras while others were live-plucked, and many were kept in poor conditions. This resulted in many companies setting standards for down supply. Here I’ve given the information currently provided by companies. Many use the Responsible Down Standard (RDS) -https://responsibledown.org/.
What other features should I look for?
Ventilation: For comfort over a wide range of temperatures a sleeping bag needs ventilation options. At the very least this should mean a long zip so the bag can be opened up and used as a quilt. Ideally this should be a two-way zip so the foot end can be opened for ventilation and if necessary, your hot feet stuck out. More sophisticated are bags with zipped panels that can be opened for more room, which as well as comfort means less warmth, or zips both sides so the top can be opened up. One unusual bag has no zips at all but a fold-over section at the top and a slot for your feet.
Warmth: For cold nights bags need to have a hood that can be closed round the head, insulated baffles behind zips, a shaped foot, and a construction without sewn-through seams – all the bags reviewed here have these.
Fill: The choice is between down and synthetic. Both come in different types. With down the higher the fill power the higher the quality and the greater the warmth for the weight. Fill power is the measure of the volume a given amount of down will fill.
Construction: To ensure there are no cold spots at the seams three-season down bags have short walls (known as baffles) that separate the lining from the outer. Synthetic bags may have overlapping layers of fill or single layers without stitching. Some bags also have more fill on the top than the bottom. This is fine as long as you turn over in the bag rather than with it as the latter moves the thinner section to the top and reduces the warmth of the bag.
Length: Some bags come in more than one length. A bag should be roomy enough that your feet aren’t pushing against the end but there shouldn’t be a large gap as this will just hold cold air (though some people like a long bag so they can store clothing in the foot).
Width: Narrow bags are the most efficient as they cut out cold spots. Many people find them too restrictive, however. Some bags come with panels that can be unzipped to create more room – these also make a bag cooler.
Hood: A good hood should fit snugly round the face and have a drawcord that is easy to adjust when it’s dark and you’re half asleep.
Draft collar: An adjustable draft collar or neck baffle in the mouth of the bag can be used to cut out drafts when you don’t want to close the hood.
Foot: Extra tubes in the foot give more room for your feet and are warmer as the fill isn’t compressed.
Zip: A zip lets you ventilate a bag and makes getting in and out easier. Bags with full-length zips can also be used as quilts on very warm nights. Two-way zips give the best heat control as you can open them a little way from the top or bottom – excellent if you suffer from hot feet! Centre zips are not quite as versatile as side zips for ventilation but do make getting in and out of the bag easier and can be opened slightly at the top when sitting up.